De Minimis
  • Home
  • ABOUT US
  • Podcast
  • Your Learned Friend
  • Anonymous Feedback
  • Art
  • Get published!
  • Constitution
  • Archive
    • 2018
    • 2017
    • 2017 >
      • Semester 2 (Volume 12) >
        • Issue 1
        • Issue 2
        • Issue 3
        • Issue 4
        • Issue 5
        • Issue 6
        • Issue 7
        • Issue 8 (election issue)
        • Issue 9
        • Issue 10
        • Issue 11
        • Issue 12
    • 2016 >
      • Semester 1 (Volume 9) >
        • Issue 1
        • Issue 2
        • Issue 3
        • Issue 4
        • Issue 5
        • Issue 6
        • Issue 7
        • Issue 8
        • Issue 9
        • Issue 10
        • Issue 11
        • Issue 12
      • Semester 2 (Volume 10) >
        • Issue 1
        • Issue 2
        • Issue 3
        • Issue 4
        • Issue 5
        • Issue 6
        • Issue 7
        • Issue 8 (Election Issue)
        • Issue 9
        • Issue 10
        • Issue 11
        • Issue 12
        • Issue 13 (test)
    • 2015 >
      • Semester 1 (Volume 7) >
        • Issue 1
        • Issue 2
        • Issue 3
        • Issue 4
        • Issue 5
        • Issue 6
        • Issue 7
        • Issue 8
        • Issue 9
        • Issue 10
        • Issue 11
      • Semester 2 (Volume 8) >
        • Issue 1
        • Issue 2
        • Issue 3
        • Issue 4
        • Issue 5
        • Issue 6
        • Issue 7
        • Issue 8
        • Issue 9
        • Issue 10
    • 2014 >
      • Semester 1 (Volume 5) >
        • Issue 1
        • Issue 2
        • Issue 3
        • Issue 4
        • Issue 5
        • Issue 6
        • Issue 7
      • Semester 2 (Volume 6) >
        • Issue 1
        • Issue 2
        • Issue 3
        • Issue 4
        • Issue 6
        • Issue 7
        • Issue 10
        • Issue 12
    • 2013 >
      • Issue 1
      • Issue 2
      • Issue 3
      • Issue 4
      • Issue 5
      • Issue 6
    • 2012 >
      • Semester 1 (Volume 1) >
        • Issue 1
        • Issue 2
        • Issue 3
        • Issue 4
        • Issue 5
        • Issue 6
        • Issue 7
        • Issue 8
        • Issue 9
        • Issue 10
        • Issue 11
        • Issue 12
      • Semester 2 (Volume 2) >
        • Issue 1
        • Issue 2
        • Issue 3
        • Issue 4
        • Issue 5
        • Issue 6
        • Issue 7
        • Issue 8
        • Issue 9
        • Issue 10
        • Issue 11
        • Issue 12

On Leaving Law School

23/5/2017

 
JOSEPH MOORE

Vol 11, Issue 12 (!)

​Towards the start of this year, I made the decision to depart from Pelham Street. My destination was around the corner, at the Melbourne Graduate School of Education. The decision has been a grand one thus far – I have always been drawn more to enthusing people about the pursuit of knowledge and challenging them to develop their thinking than engaging in crisp rules and argumentation.
Picture
So why given my longstanding love for the communication of obscure historical knowledge did I embark upon a JD? This is the real question, not why did I drop out. I do not intend this confessional to slander a fine institution with first-rate teachers. The culture of complaint and self-flagellation is strong enough at Pelham Street, without a bitter ex-student further fanning the flames.

However it wouldn’t be a De Minimis article without a bit of a carp. The ‘back to high school’ mentality that the course structure encouraged is an odd one for a cohort pushing 25 who have already experienced the anonymity of mass undergraduate degrees. Say what you will about collegiality, I found the locker rooms, netball comps and ‘LMR groups’ to be pleasant but claustrophobic and infantilising. The three or four day a week program of unrecorded seminars is a far cry from the adult experience of the Monash and RMIT JD, forcing us to be in and around the law school, buying overpriced coffee and chatting about Netflix in every ten minute break like American undergraduates.
All this may have been fine if I had been interested in the law, or genuinely desired to make a career of it out of a lust for Collins street glamour. As it is I did not. It seems I had fallen for the old lie that teaching is a sell out for the intelligent and talented.

I had also allowed myself to be tricked by the more pervasive myth that law is the correlative of the humanities. A lot of late high schoolers with an interest in literature, history, even politics, are told by parents, teachers and career advisers that they would have not only aptitude but enthusiasm for the law if they went on to study it. The part about the aptitude may be partially true, the part about enthusiasm verges on utter bollocks. The relations between the law and the humanities are more superficial than substantive, shared subject matter rather than shared methods of reasoning or concerns.

I found that the style of law itself, the rigorous application to rules as its highest virtue, has more in common with accounting or medicine. In Australia, unlike many other legal cultures, the common ‘arts law’ degree has created an indelible association in the minds of many, and one which I think is responsible for a good many law school dropouts. It is an association that many prospective law students would do well to interrogate. I learned that, though I may be interested in politics, this is very different to being interested in the law.Indeed I found the private law subjects to my surprise to be far more interesting than the more legislation driven public law ones.
My final reason returns me to waving something of a finger at the law school. Despite the disinterest outlined above, I entered law school sustained by the maxim that one ‘doesn’t need to be a lawyer’ upon finishing the course, that MLS’ graduates go to a variety of professions, only one of which is a solicitor

With the greatest respect, this is tosh. Of course you could do many things after finishing law school and you will not be looked on the poorer. That would be sound advice for an eighteen year old embarking upon a double degree at significantly less financial outlay. However to begin a significantly more expensive degree in one’s early to mid twenties, with all the opportunity cost of exercising these ‘non legal’ skills and passions over those three years, seems a dreadful waste if you are not interested in the craft you are learning. It was an extraordinary marketing coup that I could be led to believe that a three year professional masters degree for a career I didn’t wish to pursue was a good way to ‘find myself’ and work out what I really wanted to do.  To pretend that law is a new generalist degree, good to have up your sleeve, is a clever if irresponsible way of getting young people to prodigally throw their time and money at an institution, whilst acknowledging the poor job prospects that mean they will likely not have the opportunity to use that craft knowledge. Unlike medicine, work placements are not par for the course and so the cost of increasing places in a law degree is far smaller compared to what students bring in – it is in the university’s interests to peddle this line.

My confessional account has little to do with law school itself, and more to do with the myths that encourage people to do law for the wrong reasons, or no reason at all. If you want to pursue passions other than the law, I would advise you to spend these three precious years doing so. A passion for reading and a way with words are not automatic signs that you will flourish and be nourished by the law school.  And if the culture irks you and you find yourself constantly whining then, unless you are an incorrigible humbug, the problem may lie more with your decision to study a body of knowledge in which you are uninterested, and not with the institution you are finding yourself at war with.

Joseph Moore is a Masters of Education student who completed one year of the JD in 2016

The rest of this issue​
  • Coming Face to Face with Mr Adler
  • A History of the Split Profession
  • Stuff We Applied for and Did Not Get
  • How to Win Clerkships and Alienate Failure
Anon
24/5/2017 07:17:14 am

Bravo 👏 Enough said

The new rent-seekers
26/5/2017 12:31:29 pm

Just as the banking sector is seen now alongside the mining sector - making super profits that they don't deserve due to regulatory conditions - the uni sector, and especially the sandstone unis, will be seen as supposedly not-for-profit institutions that make an enormous amount of revenue for selling a public good at the highest price possible (with the 'profits' going to management and academics).

As a whole, if there was any industry that I would want to make obscene profits, it's probably education, because such revenue should attract the brightest people to the increasingly high-paying academic professions, and ultimately, stats show that those students who finish their degrees are way better off than those who don't, and can usually comfortably pay off their education fees thanks to HECS.

However, the capitalism of the demand-driven postgraduate sector should be balanced by the cheaper undergraduate sector. If law truly is a generalist degree, Melbourne Uni should have an undergrad law course (like Monash does), that costs as much as the other generalist undergrad degrees. Otherwise, one cannot justify paying $120k as a full fee-paying student for 3yrs of general skills - that is only (potentially) justifiable if you're quite sure that you will receive a relatively high-paying law job at the ending of it all...

C-A
22/7/2017 05:01:45 pm

This article is the exact same realisation I had during my second year, but I decided that the best use of my money already spent was to just go ahead and get the degree. Good luck with your Masters!


Comments are closed.
    Picture

    Archives

    October 2022
    September 2022
    December 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    December 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • ABOUT US
  • Podcast
  • Your Learned Friend
  • Anonymous Feedback
  • Art
  • Get published!
  • Constitution
  • Archive
    • 2018
    • 2017
    • 2017 >
      • Semester 2 (Volume 12) >
        • Issue 1
        • Issue 2
        • Issue 3
        • Issue 4
        • Issue 5
        • Issue 6
        • Issue 7
        • Issue 8 (election issue)
        • Issue 9
        • Issue 10
        • Issue 11
        • Issue 12
    • 2016 >
      • Semester 1 (Volume 9) >
        • Issue 1
        • Issue 2
        • Issue 3
        • Issue 4
        • Issue 5
        • Issue 6
        • Issue 7
        • Issue 8
        • Issue 9
        • Issue 10
        • Issue 11
        • Issue 12
      • Semester 2 (Volume 10) >
        • Issue 1
        • Issue 2
        • Issue 3
        • Issue 4
        • Issue 5
        • Issue 6
        • Issue 7
        • Issue 8 (Election Issue)
        • Issue 9
        • Issue 10
        • Issue 11
        • Issue 12
        • Issue 13 (test)
    • 2015 >
      • Semester 1 (Volume 7) >
        • Issue 1
        • Issue 2
        • Issue 3
        • Issue 4
        • Issue 5
        • Issue 6
        • Issue 7
        • Issue 8
        • Issue 9
        • Issue 10
        • Issue 11
      • Semester 2 (Volume 8) >
        • Issue 1
        • Issue 2
        • Issue 3
        • Issue 4
        • Issue 5
        • Issue 6
        • Issue 7
        • Issue 8
        • Issue 9
        • Issue 10
    • 2014 >
      • Semester 1 (Volume 5) >
        • Issue 1
        • Issue 2
        • Issue 3
        • Issue 4
        • Issue 5
        • Issue 6
        • Issue 7
      • Semester 2 (Volume 6) >
        • Issue 1
        • Issue 2
        • Issue 3
        • Issue 4
        • Issue 6
        • Issue 7
        • Issue 10
        • Issue 12
    • 2013 >
      • Issue 1
      • Issue 2
      • Issue 3
      • Issue 4
      • Issue 5
      • Issue 6
    • 2012 >
      • Semester 1 (Volume 1) >
        • Issue 1
        • Issue 2
        • Issue 3
        • Issue 4
        • Issue 5
        • Issue 6
        • Issue 7
        • Issue 8
        • Issue 9
        • Issue 10
        • Issue 11
        • Issue 12
      • Semester 2 (Volume 2) >
        • Issue 1
        • Issue 2
        • Issue 3
        • Issue 4
        • Issue 5
        • Issue 6
        • Issue 7
        • Issue 8
        • Issue 9
        • Issue 10
        • Issue 11
        • Issue 12